John Cochran


John Cochran, Agency Owner, purchased the agency from its founder, Jack Valentine, in 1995.  John was born and raised in the Moberly area and the agency was a perfect fit.  John is licensed in all areas of insurance; however, his main focus within the agency is individual and group life and health coverage.

Jack Valentine


Jack Valentine founded our agency in 1964.  Jack is a life-time Moberly resident with more than 50 years of insurance experience and more than 2 decades of service in the Moberly city government. Although retired, Jack is still an integral part of the agency.

Tammy Randolph


Tammy Randolph is our Senior Customer Service Representative. Tammy is licensed in Property and Casualty, and has been an agency since 1995.  She was named Agent of the Year in 1999.  Tammy’s focus within the agency is Commercial and Personal Lines service.

Lea Courter


Lea Courter has been with the agency since 2005.  She is the agency’s Administrative Assistant providing invaluable support to the Commercial Lines Department.

Sara Smothers


Sara is the Valentine Agency’s Account Manager for Health insurance policies. She serves the Health Insurance clients from A to Z, quoting, writing and servicing accounts. Sara has been with the Agency since 2008. She never fails to go the extra mile to ensure all of our clients are well cared for.

Tina Fisher


Tina is our Customer Service Representative, specializing in Personal Lines. She has been with our Agency since 2010. Tina has a very diversified background, bringing her wonderful people skills to our agency. You will be sure to leave feeling your needs have been cared for.

Kaitie Kindell


Kaitie comes to the Valentine Agency by the way of Moberly Community College. As a full time student, Kaitie is doing her apprenticeship with us serving as our receptionist, file manager and customer service representative. Her smile and cheer will make you feel at home at Valentine Insurance.

Shonelle Best


Shonelle is the newest addition to our friendly staff. She is a Personal Lines Customer Service Representative. Shonelle will work timelessly to make sure you have the right coverage to meet all of your needs.

Call Today!
(660) 263-1111 • 1-800-369-1112